Could it be harder to make the Commonwealth Games than to make the World Championships?

Cover photo of courtesy of Athletics Australia

With one selection criteria being entirely discretionary and referencing Commonwealth Top List performances, and the other cut-throat qualifying based largely on World Rankings, could it be that some athletes selected in the World Championships will miss a spot for the Commonwealth Games?

First things first: the Australian Commonwealth Games team is constrained to 68 able bodied athletes, due to a quota set by Commonwealth Games Australia. This will mean a much smaller team than the 107 selected for the Gold Coast in 2018 or the 99 selected for Glasgow in 2014.

Commonwealth Games selections are entirely discretionary for each country, without qualifying standards to meet. Athletics Australia has set a nominations policy that will see six development athletes selected, along with automatic nominations for athletes who had met the World Championships qualifying standard by the time they had won nationals.

On the other hand, the World Championships have a very objective, but highly convoluted, qualification pathway: meet a performance qualifying standard (the very objective part), or otherwise be the next best ranked athletes based on World Athletics Rankings (the convoluted bit). Australia can enter up to 3 athletes per event, without any limitation to the overall size of the team. At the last World Championships in 2019, Australia had a team of 60 athletes.

The selection criteria for the two events read differently, with one of many considerations for the Commonwealth Games being the Commonwealth Top List since 1 June 2021 (presumably on a three-per-nation basis). These are tedious to create from World Athletics Top Lists (which are based on a calendar year), but for some context we’ve created a summary of these for the women’s track events, on a three-per-nation basis.

Data presented on a three-per-nation basis, for the period 1 June 2021 to 10 June 2022.

There’s 42 individual events at the Commonwealth Games and four relays. With a maximum 68 athletes, that’s 1.6 athletes on average per individual event. To highlight some of the challenges with selection, that’s equivalent to selecting 16 athletes from the 10 events in the table above. Who do you pick? Who do you leave out? Want to pick a relay team including athletes not in individual events? Which places in other individual events do you sacrifice to do so?

Add to all of that the fact that there is less depth in more technical events in the Commonwealth compared to track events (particularly in the field), and there could be selections and priorities that could surprise. Think the women’s Heptathlon – Oceania Champion Tanielle Crase is ranked sixth in the Commonwealth in the Heptathlon on a three-per-nation basis – and an outside chance at a medal dependent on who lines up in Birmingham and how the event unfolds. She’s higher ranked than some athletes who have already been selected, like Catriona Bisset, who is 11th in her event, the 800m.

Pre the recent Oceania Championships, Australia had 66 athletes within a qualifying position for the World Championships, so roughly the same size as can be picked for the Commonwealth Games. We’ll update that list next week, but it will stay roughly the same, or increase slightly due to the hyper-inflation that Oceania Championships results bring to World Rankings.

In some events, there’s some noticeable differences between Top Lists and World Rankings, even within Australia. Consider the women’s 800m. Oceania Champion Tess Kirsopp-Cole is the second ranked Australian for World Championship selection (she was ranked 37th for a field of 48 prior to Oceania Championships, and now listed as 27th because World Athletics treats the Area Champion as having qualified. But even without that, she’ll have enough points to remain in the top 48 at the end of qualifying in 16 days time). However, she’s not ranked in the Top 5 Australians on the Commonwealth Top Lists (based on fastest times since 1 June last year), with the third ranked Australian (Imogen Barrett) being ranked 17th in the Commonwealth on a 3-per-nation basis. If you took Barrett out of consideration and put Kirsopp-Cole into the rankings, she’d sit around 21st in the Commonwealth.

With only 68 athletes being able to be selected for Commonwealth Games, does an athlete ranked 21st in their event in the Commonwealth get a spot? Or does Kirsopp-Cole get selected for the World Championships, but not for the Commonwealth Games?

The point of this discussion isn’t to single out Tess Kirsopp-Cole – she’s performed really well in her first season stepping up to the 800m – and in our view, deserves to wear the green & gold. The question is, at what championship(s)? And there’s countless other selection dilemmas that will be faced in the coming weeks for Athletics Australia’s selectors, and some interesting outcomes to be sure.

Who are your picks for the Commonwealth Games? Join the discussion on our Facebook page.

Latest posts:

• 
  Australian Top Lists
  Check out the top 8 performances by Australian athletes in the lead up to Commonwealth Games selection. With Top Lists back in vogue in the selection policy for Glasgow’s Commonwealth Games and for Oceania Championships selection (compared to prior years for World Athletics events where World Rankings ruled), here’s the performances that selectors will be… Read more: Australian Top Lists
• 
  Bol blazes as Perth turns up the heat
  Backed by a vocal home crowd in Perth, Peter Bol delivered a performance that lifted the stadium and underlined his class. Bol, 32, delivered a two-lap masterclass in the men’s 800m, clocking 1:43.89 to break the meet record and dip under 1:44 for the fifth time in 12 months. Photos by Michael Hall for Inside… Read more: Bol blazes as Perth turns up the heat
• 
  Commonwealth Games Qualifiers
  Here’s the athletes that have achieved the tough qualifying standards for the 2026 Commonwealth Games in Glasgow. With a hard cap of 63 open athletes for the Australian team, most selections will be discretionary. The only automatic pathway to selection is achieving the qualifying standard before, or while, winning the Australian Championship in April. Here’s… Read more: Commonwealth Games Qualifiers
• 
  Rewriting the Final Act: Peter Bol’s Unfinished Story
  “The challenge was to fall in love with the sport I had never fallen in love with in the first place.” Cover image by Chiara Montesano courtesy of Australian Athletics When Peter Bol saluted the crowd during the final metres of the Australian 800m final in Perth last year, we were witnessing the redemption moment… Read more: Rewriting the Final Act: Peter Bol’s Unfinished Story
• 
  Jenneke sets the tone as emerging talent steps up in Melbourne at Short Track Championships
  The Australian Short Track Championships may not have drawn the full depth of the nation’s elite, but those who did line up at the second edition of the meet found conditions that were far better than Melbourne’s reputation might suggest. Michelle Jenneke made the clearest of those statements, claiming the national 60m hurdles title in… Read more: Jenneke sets the tone as emerging talent steps up in Melbourne at Short Track Championships